torsdag 28 november 2013

Theme 4 - Quantitative research


I chose an article titled Effects of Sponsorship, Web Site Design, and Google Ranking on the credibility of Online Information from the Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication.

The article examines which impacts the sponsor credibility, Web site design appeal and search engine ranking has on the online information credibility. Two experiments were performed, one main experiment to examine the effects of Web site sponsors and Web design appeal, and one follow-up experiment to examine the effects that the Google ranking has on the results from the main experiment. Both experiments used an online survey – the first with 574 participants and the second with 274 participants, where the latter had the same questionnaire but with additional questions. The larger groups were split into smaller groups of circa 100 to compare different Web sites but answer the same questionnaire.

The qualitative data that is gathered through this method makes it possible to use statistical analysis and (eventually) generalize the results. The experiments from their study are also partially based on previous research – when previous qualitative data can be combined with the new quantitative data it can help explain the qualitative data. Because some of the result from this study can be converged with previous studies the conclusions also can get “stronger” and more credible.

The main problems with the method that I thought of when reading the paper were also problems they mentioned in their discussion. The participants were all in a young age group, if the participants were older the result could have differed, they point out that this could be a subject for a future research. I would also like to see diagrams of the collected and statistical data so the data can be visualized and more understandable.


Physical Activity, Stress, and Self-Reported Upper Respiratory Tract Infection
The paper examines the possible connection between physical activity and perceived stress, and the effects they have on the immune function. To do this they use Web-based questionnaires, one baseline and five follow-ups. The study population consisted of 1509 men and women.

In the questionnaires, they were for example asked to estimate the amount of time spent doing a physical activity or to estimate their perceived stress. The estimated time isn't the same as the time really spent and the perceived stress isn’t either the exact stress level, which also is perhaps a sign of one of the limits with quantitative data; the data can often not be analyzed at the same deeper level as quantitative data. Quantitative data makes it possible to generalize the results and come to generalizing conclusions as a difference to qualitative data. Which one of the qualitative and quantitative methods is the most useful (if not combined) depends much on what you’re researching and what questions you want answered.



2 kommentarer:

  1. Hello!
    Your chosen paper seems to be well done. I liked the idea that they did both a quantitative and a qualitative method, and even included previous qualitative research. As you wrote, it sounds like it would boost the credibility of their theory. As I've read other people's blog posts and their chosen papers, most of the papers have only chosen a quantitative method and then presented results from previous studies/literature, and then combined those to a final conclusion.
    You mentioned that there were no diagrams of the collected data in the study. I would have wanted the data to be visualized too to better comprehend the relationship between different answers and see the patterns, to complement the descriptions. Since the data would be only numbers, it might become difficult for the reader to follow along, like "10% said XX, while 35% said YY, which could be the reason why 70% answered ZZ...".

    SvaraRadera
  2. During this course we have read quite a few research papers. From my experience most of the papers I have read has had problems with their sample group. Most of the time the majority of the participants are young. The researchers often point this out in their discussion but almost every time says it can be a something for future research. It feels like they’re offloading it onto someone else but no one ever repeats their research on a more representable sample group.

    SvaraRadera