First I’ve
chosen the paper Evolving Mobile Media: Uses
and Conceptualizations of the Mobile Internet from the Journal of Computer
Mediated Communication. The paper uses qualitative methods to explore the role
of meta-communication and usage of the Internet on mobile devices. They used
semi-structured interviews with 21 college students.
Since we talked
about both qualitative and quantitative methods in the seminar on Wednesday
last week I don’t think I learnt anything more from this paper than what we
talked about then. I think I would have been more sceptical to this paper if I
we hadn’t already talked about qualitative vs. quantitative methods and how
quantitative and qualitative methods can complement each other. I can’t see that
this paper adds that much knowledge, but I could see how it gives a small base
for other future research, it for example suggests different methodologies and
research approaches for future studies.
The method used
in this study has several limitations. It can’t be generalized, and it can’t
reveal any detailed information about how the users use what the paper calls
the “mobile internet”. Although this
could instead be something for future research and to big for this research,
the qualitative method used in this study could perhaps have been better if
they also collected data about the use of Internet on mobile phones.
Briefly explain to a first year university student
what a case study is.
A case study is
a research strategy that focuses on analysing a single case or multiple cases.
These cases could be persons, groups or events and also according to Wikipedia - decisions, periods, projects, policies, institutions,
or other systems. Both quantitative and qualitative methods and combination of
these can be used and the aim of the case study could be to provide
description, test theory or generate theory.
Use the "Process of Building Theory from Case
Study Research" (Eisenhardt, summarized in Table 1) to analyze the
strengths and weaknesses of your selected paper.
I’ve chosen the
paper Campaigning on Twitter:
Microblogging and Online Social Networking as Campaign Tools in the 2010
General Elections in the Netherlands from the Journal of Computer-Mediated interaction. It focuses, as you can
see on the title, on the 2010 general elections in the Netherlands. I got a
little confused because they never mention their study to be a case study but I
think that they fill in what defines a case study, much because it uses a
specified population. I find the paper to have much of the points summarized in
the table, although it doesn’t follow the same exact process.
They develop their research questions and hypothesis from other case
studies i.e. studies from other elections in other countries. They also compare their case with the other
cases when analysing their result. I would say that this is one of the
strengths with this study. No qualitative methods are used which could be a weakness,
but as they mention it must be hard to get qualitative information from
politicians.