torsdag 28 november 2013

Theme 4 - Quantitative research


I chose an article titled Effects of Sponsorship, Web Site Design, and Google Ranking on the credibility of Online Information from the Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication.

The article examines which impacts the sponsor credibility, Web site design appeal and search engine ranking has on the online information credibility. Two experiments were performed, one main experiment to examine the effects of Web site sponsors and Web design appeal, and one follow-up experiment to examine the effects that the Google ranking has on the results from the main experiment. Both experiments used an online survey – the first with 574 participants and the second with 274 participants, where the latter had the same questionnaire but with additional questions. The larger groups were split into smaller groups of circa 100 to compare different Web sites but answer the same questionnaire.

The qualitative data that is gathered through this method makes it possible to use statistical analysis and (eventually) generalize the results. The experiments from their study are also partially based on previous research – when previous qualitative data can be combined with the new quantitative data it can help explain the qualitative data. Because some of the result from this study can be converged with previous studies the conclusions also can get “stronger” and more credible.

The main problems with the method that I thought of when reading the paper were also problems they mentioned in their discussion. The participants were all in a young age group, if the participants were older the result could have differed, they point out that this could be a subject for a future research. I would also like to see diagrams of the collected and statistical data so the data can be visualized and more understandable.


Physical Activity, Stress, and Self-Reported Upper Respiratory Tract Infection
The paper examines the possible connection between physical activity and perceived stress, and the effects they have on the immune function. To do this they use Web-based questionnaires, one baseline and five follow-ups. The study population consisted of 1509 men and women.

In the questionnaires, they were for example asked to estimate the amount of time spent doing a physical activity or to estimate their perceived stress. The estimated time isn't the same as the time really spent and the perceived stress isn’t either the exact stress level, which also is perhaps a sign of one of the limits with quantitative data; the data can often not be analyzed at the same deeper level as quantitative data. Quantitative data makes it possible to generalize the results and come to generalizing conclusions as a difference to qualitative data. Which one of the qualitative and quantitative methods is the most useful (if not combined) depends much on what you’re researching and what questions you want answered.



Theme 3 - Reflection



I found the preparations for this week theme to perhaps be more relevant for what I have expected to learn in this course than compared to previous weeks.
In the preparations we were to choose a media technology related journal and article, which we were to read critically. I found it quite hard to be critical against the article but I think it is still important to remember to read articles critically, which is something I almost always forget. In the first seminar we were divided into smaller groups where we discussed one of our articles critically, before discussing them in the larger group. Since I found  that this was a difficult part of the preparation, it was good to hear other people's views on their articles and will be helpful when reading critically in the future.

The thing I maybe found most confusing this week was the question about what theory is.  When we during the second seminar discussed this it got a bit clearer I still think it is a hard question. It is easy to forget that there is difference between theories in different disciplines, for example between technology and psychology, which could be a reason to why it gets confusing. There is, as someone pointed out in the seminar, also hard to distinguish what is a theory and what is a research field.

I think the seminar discussions and preparations for this theme will be very helpful when writing my master thesis, the more experience I get finding and reading articles the better and I also think the acquaintance with different theory types will be useful as well.
                                                                                                     

fredag 22 november 2013

Theme 3 - Research and theory


The journal I chose was the journal of Information Technology (JIT) with the impact factor of 3,532 (2012). The target group is according to the website: academics, scholars, advanced students, reflective practitioners and also those interested in updates and the future of modern information and communication technology. The focus is on new research about IT-technology and management, but also articles about that aim to improve the use of research approaches and methods. This includes for example research articles, review articles and debates.

Analysis of Social Interactions Through Mobile Phones is the title of the paper I choose. It’s published in a journal called Mobile Networks and Communication with the impact factor of 1.109. The article present and evaluates a design for monitoring social interactions through mobile phones. Previous similar monitoring solutions have included devices that caused problems when testing, like behavior changes or, when using mobile phones, privacy concerns and ethical issues. Their solution uses non-auditory sensors that exists in today’s smartphones to monitor body orientation and distance between two phones – this to measure if and what type of social interaction occurs

Briefly explain to a first year student what theory is, and what theory is not.
There are different views on what theory is, also depending on discipline. Very simplified, you could say that a theory is a way to explain why something happens or a tool to help understand, explain and make prediction about a specific topic.
Though there are different views on what theory really is there are more agreement about what is not theory. References, data, hypothesis are for example not in themselves theory; you could instead say that they are a support for the theory. As an example, a hypothesis is a statement of what is expected to occur, when theory should answer why it’s expected to occur.

Describe the major theory or theories that are used in your selected paper. Which theory type (see Table 2 in Gregor) can the theory or theories be characterized as?
In my selected paper they started by analyzing previous methods, followed by a presentation and demonstration of their developed system by presenting an experiment in which they had analyzed the results. I would say that they primarily used a “design and action”- theory, although they never really explain how the system is developed on a deeper level. It has also has element from the “analyzing” theory.

Which are the benefits and limitations of using the selected theory or theories?
By using a design and action theory the paper can be useful for future researchers. Because of testing and analyzing the system through an experiment (analyzing theory) the data that were collected should be credible and also useful when there is little (or none) previous information about a similar system. One limitation of the theory used in the paper is that doesn’t involve so much about relation between cause and effect.


torsdag 21 november 2013

Theme 2 - reflection

Because we had a lecture and a seminar this week it made a big difference of what I’ve learnt from this theme, compared to last week. Although I think my preparations were good, the lecture cleared up many things about the book. One really important thing that I took with me from the lecture was that a part of the enlightenment is to also question the enlightenment, as Adorno and Horkheimer did.

In the seminar many were critical against Adorno and Horkheimer’s maybe one-sided view on mass media, that they for example didn’t mention any good things about it. But you can of course understand their negative view because of the propaganda that spread through mass media in Germany. One question we stayed with longer was: “What is art?”. Who is Adorno to decide what is? My personal opinion is that it’s individual, and therefor maybe should be irrelevant.

Despite of the critic, a lot of things are still relevant in the book today. We talked, among other things, about the culture industries (or media industries) “promise of pleasure” and today’s interference between news and entertainment. A question that wasn’t answered in the seminar was if it is worse or better today (although you don’t have to have a this or that answer). We have more channels to reach out through but at the same time the influences from for example the Hollywood industries are bigger. Finally, the seminar also cleared up some terms, for example what is meant with “new” and “old” media.

torsdag 14 november 2013

Theme 2 - Critical media studies


What is Enlightenment?
Enlightenment is a movement that wanted to “dispel myths” and “overthrow fantasy with knowledge”. Instead of basing people’s ideas on traditions, faith and superstition they should be based on knowledge based on science. In the Enlightenment the human is believed to be “the master of nature”, a role previously held by God. 

What is the meaning and function of “myth” in Adorno and Horkheimer’s argument?
A myth is a way to explain the unexplained in the world through fictional stories. As said in the previous question, Enlightenment wants to dispel these myths. You could therefor think that “myth” and Enlightenment would be very different from each other, but this, according to Adorno and Horkheimer, is not true. What was explained through a belief in a deceiving myth is instead explained through a belief in science. They mean that “the fear of unknown” is still present in the Enlightenment, but instead of finding answers to the unknown by a belief in myth it is answered by a belief in science. There are for example similarities between an animal sacrificed in a ritual (with a reason based on myth) with an animal tortured in a lab (where the reason is based on science).

What are the “old” and “new” media that are discussed in the Dialectic of Enlightenment?
I am not sure that this is what they called “old” and “new” media but I would say that an example of a new media is the radio (a mass media technology). Here, a large number of people listen to what only a small group of people sends out (which has consequences explained in later questions). I think that what they mean with new media is the new mass media that doesn’t make any room for the old media. The old media is then the media that doesn’t fit in the form of new media, for example a book or a painting that isn’t mass-produced.

What is meant by “culture industry”?
Culture industry is the result of what modernization has done to culture. What is culture is know decided by those who run the industry, those who are in charge. In the same way, the consumers cultural needs are know decided by those with power of the industries and technology, those with the strongest economic position in society.

What is the relationship between mass media and “mass deception”, according to Adorno and Horkheimer?
As said in the previous question, those with the highest economic position in society are in control of the culture industry. When mass media is controlled by a small group of people, the opinions of a large number of people can be shaped by the opinions of only a small group - “The whole world is passed through the filter of the culture industry”. According to Adorno and Horkheimer mass media doesn’t promote any reflective or critical thoughts, which makes it easy to spread propaganda. 

Please identify one or two concepts/terms that you find particularly interesting. Motivate your choice.
It would be interesting to see what Adorno and Horkheimer would have to say about the Internet and what positive and negative effects it has made on the culture industry. The Internet is a much more interactive media which helps bring forward critical and reflective thoughts, and makes room for culture that is not only popular to the masses. But still, advertisements are for example more widespread which perhaps would be one of the negative effects. 
In the same way, another concept that would be interesting to know what they would have to say about today is the Enlightenment thoughts about man as “masters of nature” and its relations to the climate issues.

Theme 1 - Reflection


Since there was no lecture or seminar this week it made it harder to reflect on the theme. I think a lecture and maybe especially a seminar are for sure needed to help sort out all of the thoughts after reading such a long philosophical text, a text which perhaps got more and more confusing the more I read. Despite that, I think I got most of Russell’s points, maybe not displayed in correct answers but after reading other peoples blog posts. But still, a discussion in a seminar would really make it a lot clearer.

The subject is interesting because it discusses something we don’t really question a lot. What can we really know for sure and what is knowledge? Sense data and ourselves are pretty much the only things we know for sure according to Russell, if I remember correctly. I really liked the term sense data because I felt that it gave our senses a more important part of knowledge. As an example, many often think of art studies as perhaps a “fuzzy” subject, but art has a lot to do with sense data, so wouldn’t these studies be more based on knowledge then studying for example technology?

fredag 8 november 2013

Theme1 - Theory of Science


Sense data
The term “sense data” is introduced to help clarify the difference between the appearance of objects and what they really are, or if they even exist.

An object can appear in a variety of ways depending on the different circumstances in which we interact with the object. It could be perceived as different depending on, for example, from which angle the object is viewed. We therefor don’t really know the “reality” of the object itself, which one of the perception is the “correct”, or is there even a correct one? What we do know is what our senses can detect at the precise moment we see the object. Sense data is thus what we sense immediately. Another is the color or an object - which could depend on how the light sets at that certain moment. We can’t know for sure if the object, or matter, really exist, but what we know for sure is what our senses collect. That is sense data.

Proposition & Statement of Facts
A “proposition” is a description of something, which could be either true or false. This could also differ from person to person, what I believe is true may not be the same as what you believe is true. A statement of fact is a description, or proposition, that is regarded as “proved” as true. You should be able to prove and have correct evidence for your statement of fact. 

Russell explains that the foundation of our knowledge is based on acquaintances, which in turn comes from what we experience. I think that Russell means that the difference between propositions and statements of facts from other expressions is that they consist of acquaintances, which in turn comes from experiences. By putting them together an object can be described without the need of you experiencing the object itself.

Definite description
With a definite description Russell means a phrase that describes one specific object or person. The definite description must refer to one single object, appose to the ambiguous description, which can point to more then one. When describing a specific object, the description could still vary depending on, for example, who is the describer, but the definite description still points to the same object. “A brown horse” could be any horse, but “the brown horse” is a definite description that only points to one object.

Problems in theory of knowledge
One of the problems Russell discusses is the difference between ”true belief” and knowledge. What you believe is true could be right even though you have no real knowledge to what you believe - "a true belief is not knowledge when it is deduced from a false belief".  For example, you could theoretically have a correct answer on your math quiz, but that doesn’t mean that your problem was solved in a correct way.

In chapter 14, Russell is also critical to the view that every object is a fragment of a bigger thing – “a Whole”. He means that this is a self-contradictory and an insufficient view.