The journal I chose was the journal of Information Technology (JIT)
with the impact factor of 3,532 (2012). The target group is according to the
website: academics, scholars, advanced students, reflective practitioners and
also those interested in updates and the future of modern information and
communication technology. The focus is on new research about IT-technology and
management, but also articles about that aim to improve the use of research
approaches and methods. This includes for example research articles, review
articles and debates.
Analysis of Social Interactions Through Mobile Phones is the title of the paper I choose. It’s published in a journal called Mobile Networks and Communication
with the impact factor of 1.109. The article present and evaluates a design for
monitoring social interactions through mobile phones. Previous similar monitoring
solutions have included devices that caused problems when testing, like
behavior changes or, when using mobile phones, privacy concerns and ethical
issues. Their solution uses non-auditory sensors that exists in today’s
smartphones to monitor body orientation and distance between two phones – this
to measure if and what type of social interaction occurs
Briefly explain to a first year student what theory is, and what theory
is not.
There are different views on what
theory is, also depending on discipline. Very simplified, you could say that a
theory is a way to explain why something happens or a tool to help understand,
explain and make prediction about a specific topic.
Though there are different views on
what theory really is there are more agreement about what is not theory.
References, data, hypothesis are for example not in themselves theory; you could
instead say that they are a support for the theory. As an example, a hypothesis
is a statement of what is expected to occur, when theory should answer why it’s
expected to occur.
Describe the major theory or theories that are used in your selected
paper. Which theory type (see Table 2 in Gregor) can the theory or theories be
characterized as?
In my selected paper they started by
analyzing previous methods, followed by a presentation and demonstration of
their developed system by presenting an experiment in which they had analyzed
the results. I would say that they primarily used a “design and action”-
theory, although they never really explain how the system is developed on a
deeper level. It has also has element from the “analyzing” theory.
Which are the benefits and limitations of using the selected theory or
theories?
By using a design and action theory the
paper can be useful for future researchers. Because of testing and analyzing
the system through an experiment (analyzing theory) the data that were
collected should be credible and also useful when there is little (or none)
previous information about a similar system. One limitation of the theory used in the
paper is that doesn’t involve so much about relation between cause and effect.
I think that you summarized the question of what theory is very well and you supply valid arguments on which theories the authors of your paper use, and why they do it. However I think that one important benefit (that you didn't talk so much about) of using the design and action theory is that the complete model can be examined in other aspects, like completeness, simplicity and ease of use (Gregor 2006). Even though the model may not be relevant to a specific situation it can still be examined on these criteria. Or maybe this is what you were aiming at when you talk about "testing and analyzing the system through an experiment"?
SvaraRadera