torsdag 19 december 2013

Theme 6 - Reflection


This week the theme was quantitative and case study research. I have always thought that qualitative methods are less scientific than quantitative methods, maybe because they don’t result in generalizable data and it seems like they would fit other disciplines better than technology. It also seems much harder to use qualitative methods, to for example interview and afterwards analyze the interview. Last weeks seminar and reading other blog posts has made me a bit more positive against this method but it’s still hard for me to appreciate reading articles based on qualitative methods if not complemented with quantitative methods. It seems easier to follow up and go back and look at the result of a quantitative method. In qualitative methods you can’t use statistic and it seems harder to draw conclusions from the result. One thing that I think makes qualitative methods more useful is when having a focus group, or when doing a case study with a specific population. 

I hadn’t before this course reflected on all the different research strategies that we have went through in this course. This is something, as I have mentioned in previous blog posts, I wish I would have experienced before writing my bachelor thesis.

fredag 13 december 2013

Theme 6 - Qualitative and case study research

First I’ve chosen the paper Evolving Mobile Media: Uses and Conceptualizations of the Mobile Internet from the Journal of Computer Mediated Communication.  The paper uses qualitative methods to explore the role of meta-communication and usage of the Internet on mobile devices. They used semi-structured interviews with 21 college students.

Since we talked about both qualitative and quantitative methods in the seminar on Wednesday last week I don’t think I learnt anything more from this paper than what we talked about then. I think I would have been more sceptical to this paper if I we hadn’t already talked about qualitative vs. quantitative methods and how quantitative and qualitative methods can complement each other. I can’t see that this paper adds that much knowledge, but I could see how it gives a small base for other future research, it for example suggests different methodologies and research approaches for future studies.  

The method used in this study has several limitations. It can’t be generalized, and it can’t reveal any detailed information about how the users use what the paper calls the  “mobile internet”. Although this could instead be something for future research and to big for this research, the qualitative method used in this study could perhaps have been better if they also collected data about the use of Internet on mobile phones.
 
Briefly explain to a first year university student what a case study is.
A case study is a research strategy that focuses on analysing a single case or multiple cases. These cases could be persons, groups or events and also according to Wikipedia - decisions, periods, projects, policies, institutions, or other systems. Both quantitative and qualitative methods and combination of these can be used and the aim of the case study could be to provide description, test theory or generate theory.

Use the "Process of Building Theory from Case Study Research" (Eisenhardt, summarized in Table 1) to analyze the strengths and weaknesses of your selected paper.
I’ve chosen the paper Campaigning on Twitter: Microblogging and Online Social Networking as Campaign Tools in the 2010 General Elections in the Netherlands from the Journal of Computer-Mediated interaction. It focuses, as you can see on the title, on the 2010 general elections in the Netherlands. I got a little confused because they never mention their study to be a case study but I think that they fill in what defines a case study, much because it uses a specified population. I find the paper to have much of the points summarized in the table, although it doesn’t follow the same exact process.

They develop their research questions and hypothesis from other case studies i.e. studies from other elections in other countries.  They also compare their case with the other cases when analysing their result. I would say that this is one of the strengths with this study. No qualitative methods are used which could be a weakness, but as they mention it must be hard to get qualitative information from politicians.




torsdag 12 december 2013

Theme 5 - Reflection


This week’s theme was design research, which I found the most interesting theme so far. I unfortunately missed the first lecture on Wednesday but I made it to the second one, with Haibo Li as a lecturer.

Haibo Li talked from an engineering perspective, which was perhaps one of the things that made the lecture interesting. Together with the preparations for this week’s theme, what he talked about feels the most relevant to me as a media technology student comparing with perhaps other things we talked about in the course. But it’s possible that I only imagine this because prototyping and design research is more fun to read about than questionnaires etc.

He talked about the importance of the research question, which I think will be good to remember in the future. This is also something I got some experience with when writing the bachelor thesis (?). It took some time for us to come up with the right question, we also changed it several times and I don’t think we ended up with the ultimate question in the end. If we had a better (and more interesting) question to work with from the beginning I think we would have ended up with a much better essay. He mentioned that researchers focused 10% on coming up with the question and 90% on solving it when it according to him should be the opposite, although I found this a bit exaggerated I think he has a good point.

torsdag 5 december 2013

Theme 5 - Design Research


Comics, Robots, Fashion and Programming: Outlining the concept of actDresses
This paper introduced a new subject to me through their concept of actDresses. Most programming is done with a screen display as a medium. In physical programming it’s hard to perceive what the programmed behaviour will look like when the programming is done separate from the product. Part of the concept is to use physical markings and the signs of these markings to control the behaviour of the product.  The paper explores how the semiotics of fashion and comics can inspire physical language design, since they have “specific semiotic qualities”. 

Signs can be interpreted different in different cultures as mentioned in the paper, but I also wonder if it’s more to consider than that. If you use a certain clothes item to represent a specific behaviour, couldn’t this easily be built on prejudice?  

I haven’t much experience with reading design research papers so this paper gave me an introduction of how a design research could be performed. Except from of course learning about their concept, something I will take with me from this paper is that it’s reminds me that you can use different theories (like semiotic theory) in combination with technology when doing research. 

Turn Your Mobile Into the Ball: Rendering Live Football Game Using Vibration
Unlike the last paper this research had developed a prototype for their concept, which made a huge difference to me when understanding, believing in and also visualizing their concept. A big part of this is that you have could see real data and visualisation compared to the last paper that only had pictures.
.
With a prototype you minimize the risk of getting unexpected problems, because you have tested the prototype before producing the real product.  Prototypes could also be used to test if a consumer would even be interested in the product as in this case. A limitation with prototypes is that they are often compromised in the design and functions compared to the real product. This could also be a good thing when it costs more to develop the real product and you have to change it. I think prototypes are especially important for media technology compared to other areas because I think it’s the best way to test the interaction between human and computer

In the experiment done in the paper the users had training before the real testing took place but you still don’t know how a longer period of using the product/prototype would affect the use. There could also be a difference in the users interest of a product for new users and old users, because you are often more interested in a product when new to it.

Theme 4 - Reflection


This week the theme was quantitative methods. Unfortunately I missed the first seminar of the week but I still think I learnt a lot from by going to the second one and reading other students blog posts. One thing I’ve found hard to do on the papers we read this and last week is to be critical when reading them. It would therefor have been interesting to hear more what others had to say more about their papers in the seminar I missed, in addition to reading the blog posts.

The most important thing I think I will take with me from this week is the pros and cons of quantitative methods vs. qualitative methods, which gave me a better understanding of when to use what and also how they can complement each other. We talked for example about how qualitative methods can give deeper insights and more detailed information. Qualitative methods is also useful if you only have access to a small group of people for the research and they also give you the possibility to modify the, for example, interview by asking follow-up questions. Quantitative methods instead give you the possibility to generalize the results and compare the results to previous studies. Some of things we talked about were new to me, for example the expensive cost of producing and distributing a questionnaire. We also talked about the pros and cons with web vs. paper questionnaires and how to construct (and not to construct) a questionnaire. For example give

There are really a lot of things to take in consideration when doing research, a reason to why this course feels useful later when writing my master thesis.

torsdag 28 november 2013

Theme 4 - Quantitative research


I chose an article titled Effects of Sponsorship, Web Site Design, and Google Ranking on the credibility of Online Information from the Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication.

The article examines which impacts the sponsor credibility, Web site design appeal and search engine ranking has on the online information credibility. Two experiments were performed, one main experiment to examine the effects of Web site sponsors and Web design appeal, and one follow-up experiment to examine the effects that the Google ranking has on the results from the main experiment. Both experiments used an online survey – the first with 574 participants and the second with 274 participants, where the latter had the same questionnaire but with additional questions. The larger groups were split into smaller groups of circa 100 to compare different Web sites but answer the same questionnaire.

The qualitative data that is gathered through this method makes it possible to use statistical analysis and (eventually) generalize the results. The experiments from their study are also partially based on previous research – when previous qualitative data can be combined with the new quantitative data it can help explain the qualitative data. Because some of the result from this study can be converged with previous studies the conclusions also can get “stronger” and more credible.

The main problems with the method that I thought of when reading the paper were also problems they mentioned in their discussion. The participants were all in a young age group, if the participants were older the result could have differed, they point out that this could be a subject for a future research. I would also like to see diagrams of the collected and statistical data so the data can be visualized and more understandable.


Physical Activity, Stress, and Self-Reported Upper Respiratory Tract Infection
The paper examines the possible connection between physical activity and perceived stress, and the effects they have on the immune function. To do this they use Web-based questionnaires, one baseline and five follow-ups. The study population consisted of 1509 men and women.

In the questionnaires, they were for example asked to estimate the amount of time spent doing a physical activity or to estimate their perceived stress. The estimated time isn't the same as the time really spent and the perceived stress isn’t either the exact stress level, which also is perhaps a sign of one of the limits with quantitative data; the data can often not be analyzed at the same deeper level as quantitative data. Quantitative data makes it possible to generalize the results and come to generalizing conclusions as a difference to qualitative data. Which one of the qualitative and quantitative methods is the most useful (if not combined) depends much on what you’re researching and what questions you want answered.



Theme 3 - Reflection



I found the preparations for this week theme to perhaps be more relevant for what I have expected to learn in this course than compared to previous weeks.
In the preparations we were to choose a media technology related journal and article, which we were to read critically. I found it quite hard to be critical against the article but I think it is still important to remember to read articles critically, which is something I almost always forget. In the first seminar we were divided into smaller groups where we discussed one of our articles critically, before discussing them in the larger group. Since I found  that this was a difficult part of the preparation, it was good to hear other people's views on their articles and will be helpful when reading critically in the future.

The thing I maybe found most confusing this week was the question about what theory is.  When we during the second seminar discussed this it got a bit clearer I still think it is a hard question. It is easy to forget that there is difference between theories in different disciplines, for example between technology and psychology, which could be a reason to why it gets confusing. There is, as someone pointed out in the seminar, also hard to distinguish what is a theory and what is a research field.

I think the seminar discussions and preparations for this theme will be very helpful when writing my master thesis, the more experience I get finding and reading articles the better and I also think the acquaintance with different theory types will be useful as well.