Since there was no
lecture or seminar this week it made it harder to reflect on the theme. I think
a lecture and maybe especially a seminar are for sure needed to help sort out
all of the thoughts after reading such a long philosophical text, a text which
perhaps got more and more confusing the more I read. Despite that, I think I
got most of Russell’s points, maybe not displayed in correct answers but after
reading other peoples blog posts. But still, a discussion in a seminar would
really make it a lot clearer.
The subject is interesting because it discusses something we don’t
really question a lot. What can we really know for sure and what is knowledge?
Sense data and ourselves are pretty much the only things we know for sure
according to Russell, if I remember correctly. I really liked the term sense
data because I felt that it gave our senses a more important part of knowledge.
As an example, many often think of art studies as perhaps a “fuzzy” subject,
but art has a lot to do with sense data, so wouldn’t these studies be more based
on knowledge then studying for example technology?
I agree with you that we get some knowledge by sense-data. But there are a lot of physically challenged people with different breaches in perception. In this case we can say that our knowledge is very different from their.
SvaraRaderaYou present a interesting question with regards to the importance of sense-data in the study of art compared to sense-data in the study of technology and some of the points Russell makes in his text can certainly seem to support this. But I think that the main different is not whether one "uses" more sense-data than the other but rather what it is trying to understand. Usually art studies work on understanding the work in regards to the creator of the work and the context in which it was created while the study of technology and science tries to understand the world around us and since it is no way of achieving or empirically show the "probable opinion" towards what the former is trying to understand it is possible to do so with the latter.
SvaraRadera